A Lower Price Doesn’t Always Mean a Better Deal
Let’s say you’re planning a new metal building.
You’ve talked with a couple of contractors, explained what you want, and started getting prices.
One recommends a pre-engineered metal building. Another offers a welded-frame building that costs considerably less.
And now you’re wondering why you’d spend the extra money.
It’s a reasonable question.
After all, both buildings have steel frames. Both can be enclosed with metal panels. And from the outside, you might not notice much difference between them.
So what exactly are you paying for?
At Rigid Building Group, we build both pre-engineered metal buildings (PEMBs) and welded-frame buildings, and we have this conversation with customers regularly.
Sometimes the less expensive building is the right choice.
Other times, we believe the additional investment in a PEMB is well worth it.
The difference comes down to what you’re building, how you plan to use it, and what you expect from it over the long term.
The Difference Starts Before Construction
If you’re comparing a welded-frame building with a PEMB, you might wonder whether the difference is simply how they’re put together.
And that’s certainly part of it.
Welded-frame buildings use welded connections, while PEMBs typically use fabricated components that are bolted together on-site.
But the real question is what goes into designing the building before those components ever reach the jobsite.
For us, the bigger distinction is the engineering behind the building.
Many lower-cost welded-frame packages are based on an existing engineered design. The manufacturer has developed a particular structure and offers that design to multiple customers.
That can be an economical approach, provided the design is suitable for the project and meets the applicable requirements.
But just because a building has an engineer’s stamp doesn’t mean that same design is appropriate for every location or use.
With a PEMB, the engineering is developed around the specific project.
The location, intended use, structural loads, dimensions, openings, and other requirements all help determine the finished design.
We explored that distinction in greater detail in our previous article, What Makes Pre-Engineered Metal Buildings Custom?
The important thing to understand here is that you’re not necessarily comparing two different ways of assembling the same building.
You may be comparing two very different approaches to designing it.
When Does a Welded Metal Building Make Sense?
We don’t believe every project needs a fully customized pre-engineered structure.
Let’s say you want a shop behind your house.
Maybe you need somewhere to work on your truck, store a boat, or keep your tools and equipment out of the weather.
You’re not planning to operate a large business from the building. You’re not expecting a lot of visitors. You just need a practical space that fits your property and your budget.
Depending on the design and local requirements, a welded-frame building might make perfect sense.
We see similar situations with agricultural buildings, RV and boat storage, and certain self-storage facilities.
For these applications, a simpler building package can offer the functionality the owner needs without the additional expense of a more customized system.
And because we build welded structures ourselves, we understand what goes into doing that work properly.
When we construct them, we use full-seam welds and incorporate additional steel bracing where the design calls for it.
We don’t view a lower-cost building as an excuse to lower our workmanship standards.
But there’s a point where the intended use of the building changes our recommendation.
Who’s Going to Be Inside Your Building?
One of the first things we want to understand about any project is how the building will be used.
Not just what you’re going to store inside it.
Who’s going to be there? How often? What kind of activity will take place? What does the building need to accommodate?
Those questions can change the conversation considerably.
A storage building that someone enters occasionally is different from a commercial facility where employees work every day.
And a building that regularly accommodates hundreds of people deserves a particularly careful evaluation.
We once spoke with a church that wanted to construct a new building for its congregation.
The church was considering a welded-frame building because it would save approximately $100,000.
We understood the appeal of those savings.
But the congregation had around 250 members, and the building would be occupied several days a week.
Based on the proposed design and intended use, we weren’t comfortable recommending that particular building approach.
Ultimately, we decided not to take the project.
The church went forward with another contractor, and the building is still standing.
That experience doesn’t mean welded buildings are inherently unsafe. A properly engineered welded structure can be designed for demanding applications.
But we weren’t satisfied that the proposal being considered was the right solution for that church.
And when we’re talking about a building that will regularly accommodate that many people, we aren’t willing to make a recommendation based on price alone.
Why Does a Pre-Engineered Metal Building Cost More?
When someone asks us about pre-engineered metal building cost, we try to explain what they’re getting for the additional investment.
The price isn’t simply a reflection of how much steel goes into the building.
A PEMB involves engineering that accounts for the requirements of the individual project.
Depending on the building, that can include:
- Local wind and seismic conditions
- Intended use and occupancy
- Roof and structural loads
- Doors, windows, and other openings
- Equipment supported by the structure
- Exterior materials and architectural features
- Foundation and connection requirements
- Potential plans for future expansion
The engineering and documentation involved can contribute to the upfront cost.
A simpler welded building package may cost less because it uses an existing design with fewer project-specific options.
But that doesn’t necessarily make the two proposals equivalent.
And it doesn’t mean a PEMB will always cost more. The actual difference depends on the building, its requirements, and what’s included in each contractor’s scope.
The better question is whether the additional investment provides something your project actually needs.
What Are You Getting for the Additional Investment?
Beyond the engineering itself, there are several reasons we often recommend PEMBs for commercial projects.
A building designed around its intended use. Rather than starting with a standard package and working within its limitations, we can develop a design that accounts for the customer’s particular requirements.
Customization Beyond the Basics. A PEMB gives us flexibility in everything from the building’s dimensions and structural layout to its doors, windows, and exterior appearance. Some of the buildings we’ve worked on hardly look like metal buildings at all.
Project-specific engineering documentation. Structural drawings and supporting information can be valuable when you’re obtaining permits, evaluating future modifications, or planning additional work.
More options for the future. What works for your business today may not be what you need ten years from now. Depending on how it’s originally designed, a PEMB can give you more flexibility to make changes down the road.
That’s worth considering when you’re investing in a building you expect to use for years.
Will This Building Still Work for You Ten Years From Now?
It’s easy to focus on what you need today.
You know how much space you want, what you’re planning to put inside, and how much you can afford to spend.
But businesses change.
You may need additional space in a few years. You may purchase new equipment. You may decide to sell the property or move your operation somewhere else.
Those possibilities are worth discussing before construction begins.
One advantage of many PEMB systems is that their bolted construction can make certain future modifications or disassembly projects more practical.
We’ve worked on projects where pre-engineered buildings were taken apart and relocated.
With welded construction, disassembly can involve cutting existing connections and performing additional fabrication to prepare the components for reuse.
Expansion presents another consideration.
If we know there’s a possibility you’ll want to add onto a PEMB later, we can discuss that with the engineering team during the original design process.
That doesn’t mean a PEMB can be expanded or moved without additional engineering.
Any proposed changes need to be evaluated to make sure the structure will meet the requirements of its new configuration or location.
Still, having a building that’s been designed and documented with future possibilities in mind can be a valuable advantage.
And when you’re making a substantial investment in a commercial building, having options matters.
Before You Compare Prices, Compare What’s Included
Here’s something we encounter all the time.
A customer calls and tells us another contractor can build the same thing for $50,000 less.
Our response?
Compared to what?
Because when we start looking at the details, we sometimes find that the competing proposal doesn’t include everything the customer originally requested.
And that’s not necessarily because someone is trying to mislead anybody.
Sometimes the customer hasn’t fully explained what they need. Sometimes the contractor hasn’t asked enough questions. Sometimes the two parties have different ideas about what the finished building is supposed to include.
We recently had a conversation with someone planning to build a winery.
The customer wanted a price, but the project requirements were still pretty vague.
A winery may need more than a basic building shell.
Depending on the operation, there could be specialized drainage, sanitation requirements, or concrete designed to accommodate heavy equipment and materials.
If one contractor includes those features and another doesn’t, you’re going to see a difference in price.
But you’re also getting two very different proposals.
If one contractor accounts for those requirements and another simply prices an enclosed building, the estimates are going to look very different.
But they’re not estimates for the same project.
That’s why we spend time asking questions before putting together a proposal.
We want to know what the building needs to accomplish, what features are essential, and what the customer can realistically afford.
If the budget won’t support everything on the wish list, we’d rather talk about it.
Maybe there’s a way to simplify the design. Maybe certain features can be added later. Maybe we need to rethink the scope altogether.
But we can’t have that conversation effectively if we don’t understand what the customer needs or what they’re prepared to invest.
Choosing the Best Long-Term Investment for Your Project
So, is a pre-engineered metal building worth the extra cost?
In many commercial applications, we believe it is.
But that doesn’t mean we’d recommend one for every project.
A straightforward storage building and a commercial facility occupied by dozens of people every day have very different requirements.
And the right choice depends on more than how much money you can save upfront.
We want to understand how you’re going to use the building, what you’re planning to put inside it, what your budget looks like, and what you might need from it in the future.
Then we can help you evaluate the options.
At Rigid Building Group, our goal isn’t to sell you the most expensive metal building we can.
It’s to help you make the best long-term investment for your project.
That’s what we mean when we say Built to Last.